Grand Theft Autonomy: Restricting Consumer Ownership of Entertainment Mediums

Give a man a fish, he eats for a day; teach a man to fish, he eats for a lifetime. This mantra of self-sufficiency and sustainability has been ingrained in Americans since its first iteration in 1885 [1]. However, Ms. Ritchie's version of the phrase omits a glaringly obvious and lucrative third option: own the ocean, and price-gouge fishermen for the right to use it.
The move of entertainment companies to digital platforms has provided the foundation necessary to adopt this third option. For example, in the yesteryear of Blockbuster and Family Videos, a kid who liked Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed could go to a brick-and-mortar rental store, pay somewhere between $1-$3 per night [2], and physically possess the movie. This child would have the option to keep it until the movie was due, incur growing late fees, or decide to keep it indefinitely. Moreover, a child who loved Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed and Linda Cardellini as Velma could buy it outright and own it forever – allowing them to watch it every day if they pleased.
This is no longer the norm. Streaming platforms drove entertainment brick-and-mortar stores out of business [3]. Streaming platforms have eliminated the ability for subscribers to have ownership over digital titles. Subscribers to a streaming service pay for a license that gives them the right to access a product for a specified amount of time determined by a licensor like Netflix [4]. In effect, the consumer has no right to complain when Netflix removes "Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life," because they never possessed actual ownership rights [5]. Not to mention that it was kind of garbage, and probably best forgotten about anyway.
And this makes sense, at least for a streaming model. After all, it is difficult to imagine a subscriber could believe they actively own all the titles on a streaming service. Although the question of whether the perpetual state of renting is good for society is worthwhile, the water gets murkier when it comes to digital ownership. The proliferation of streaming platforms has been accompanied by a move to digital "ownership," with a concomitant decline in sales of physical media [6]. However, this "ownership" is actually an extension of the same licensing model used by the streaming platforms [7].
"Purchased Digital Content will generally continue to be available for you for download or stream from the Service, as applicable, but may become unavailable due to potential content provider licensing restrictions or for other reasons, and Amazon will not be liable to you if Purchased Digital Content becomes unavailable for download or streaming" [8].
This is not an example from the “How to Draft as Vaguely as Possible to Protect Your Corporate Client” textbook – this is exact language from Amazon’s terms of agreement upon purchasing any digital content with added emphasis. Similar language can also be found in other online distributors like the Google Play Store [9]. In essence, a purchaser of any digital “property” from a platform with this disclaiming language can have their purchase revoked, without warning or restitution.
A lawsuit based on Amazon’s aforementioned language was dismissed for lack of standing, as the plaintiff never actually lost access to the titles she purchased [10]. However, this ruling does not mean the issue is nonexistent – rather, we can look to a different, but related field: video games. Like movies, video games were rentable from brick-and-mortar stores, have now been largely digitized, and have experienced precipitous drops in physical sales [11]. Unlike movies, however, there is a specific example of a game company revoking its players’ digital property. In 2024, Ubisoft shut down access to one of its games, The Crew [12]. Unlike other server shutdowns, relatively common for outdated, yearly-release games like Madden and Call of Duty, Ubisoft revoked player access to single-player modes and separately purchased DLCs. Eventually, this company went so far as to unilaterally remove the game entirely from players’ console libraries [13]. Ubisoft claims it had full legal authority for this, despite players having paid full price for both the game and, in many cases, subsequent DLCs. Ubisoft argued these players should have been aware that what they were actually buying was the right to be allowed to play subject to Ubisoft’s discretion. In other words: a license [14].
This worst-case scenario appears to have a simple solution: to stop digital purchasing. As usual, however, “Big-Money” is one step ahead. The option to physically purchase is slowly being eliminated, nominally to reduce waste and costs—but in actuality to herd consumers toward a more controllable and revocable status of subjugated lease holding. The most flagrant example is the upcoming release of GTA VI. As one of the most anticipated games of the last decade, there will be a physical case available to purchase; however, this case will not include an actual disc. Instead, the case will contain a download code, the input of which will entitle the buyer to . . . a digital license of the game [15]. This digital license equates to a book whose pages are filled with links to the Kindle store, or cupboards stocked not with food—but DoorDash QR codes.
This digital tyranny is not inevitable. First, there is an ongoing lawsuit over the Ubisoft decision, which could determine what it means to have “ownership” over digital property [16]. Second, House Member Richie Torres has introduced a bill designed to “ensure” video game players actually own the games they buy [17]. However, these are neither the most direct nor most effective way to reassert ownership rights.
The largest lever of power to change corporate behavior is consumer choice. Given the increasingly digital world, the ease and convenience afforded by digitally accessible entertainment is undoubtedly alluring. Nonetheless, this allure has turned into complacency, and in turn, has become exploitable. The path forward is to reverse it. Buy a console with a disc drive instead of one without. Unsubscribe from Netflix the next time it raises prices or introduces more ads. Rummage through the $5 DVD bins at Wal-Mart. Show the entertainment companies that there still is a viable and financially exploitable consumer interest in tangible ownership rights. Otherwise, these companies will continue operating under their current assumption – sell a man a disc, profit for a day; sell a man a license, profit for a lifetime.
Resources
[1] Anne Thackeray Ritchie, Mrs. Dymond 342 (1885) (“[I]f you give a man a fish he is hungry again in an hour. If you teach him to catch a fish you do him a good turn.”)
[2] Craig Shoup, Family Video Still Connects with Movie Lovers, News-Messenger (Fremont, Ohio) (Mar. 27, 2017), https://www.thenews-messenger.com/story/money/companies/locally-in-business/2017/03/27/family-video-still-connects-movie-lovers/99579582/.
[3] Brent Lang, Netflix’s Origin Story: How the Streamer Killed Blockbuster Video, Snagged ‘House of Cards’ from HBO, and Changed Hollywood Forever, Variety (Mar. 20, 2025), https://variety.com/2025/film/news/netflix-history-killed-blockbuster-dominated-hollywood-1236342853/.
[4] David Fowler, Subscription-Based Ownership: The End of Property?, Campbell L. Observer (Feb. 1, 2022), https://campbelllawobserver.com/subscription-based-ownership-the-end-of-property/.
[5] Id.
[6] Cerys Davies, DVDs are the New Vinyl Records: Why Gen Z is Embracing Physical Media, L.A. Times (Feb. 23, 2026), https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/business/story/2026-02-23/why-gen-z-wants-to-buy-rent-dvds-blu-rays-in-age-of-streaming.
[7] Geoffrey Morrison, You Don’t Really Own the Digital Movies You Buy, Wirecutter (Aug. 4, 2021), https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/you-dont-own-your-digital-movies/.
[8] Id.
[9] Id.
[10] Caudel v. Amazon.com, Inc., No. 20-cv-00848-KJM-KJN, slip op. at 4–5 (E.D. Cal. Oct. 15, 2021).
[11] Sophie McEvoy, US Physical Game Sales Drop to Lowest Monthly Total Since 1995, GamesIndustry.biz (Aug. 20, 2026), https://www.gamesindustry.biz/us-physical-game-sales-drop-to-lowest-monthly-total-since-1995-us-monthly-charts.
[12] Vikki Blake, Ubisoft’s The Crew Lawsuit Insists We Do Not Own the Games We Buy, IGN (Apr. 10, 2025), https://www.ign.com/articles/ubisofts-the-crew-lawsuit-insists-we-do-not-own-the-games-we-buy.
[13] Id.
[14] Id.
[15] Grand Theft Auto VI Platforms, Editions, and Versions, Rockstar Games Customer Support (last updated Aug. 18, 2026), https://support.rockstargames.com/articles/4QfG4FmZCf5W1gS8jy4UVT/grand-theft-auto-vi-platform-editions-and-versions.
[16] Vikki Blake, Ubisoft’s The Crew Lawsuit Insists We Do Not Own the Games We Buy, IGN (Apr. 10, 2025), https://www.ign.com/articles/ubisofts-the-crew-lawsuit-insists-we-do-not-own-the-games-we-buy.
[17] Press Release, Rep. Ritchie Torres, Rep. Torres Announces Power to the Players Act, Legislation to Ensure Gamers Own Their Games (Oct. 15, 2026), https://ritchietorres.house.gov/posts/rep-torres-announces-power-to-the-players-act-legislation-to-ensure-gamers-own-their-games.





Comments